Christian Dube's Misrepresents Dr. Rosenberg

Add Dube to the list of CAQers spewing disingenuous information.

This is where we are on the 2020 timeline. Where the government SILENCES actual experts.

We're in a situation now where the government is now actively censoring dissenting opinions from experts.

Quebec is acting very much as you'd expect from it. They make the case for why I'm jealous we don't have a Second Amendment. Legault thinks he's so fucken smart thinking he's fooling people. He's not even a good liar.

It's a complete sham and farce.

Let's break into the Dube's false attack on Dr. Rosenberg. Read the blood boiling idiocy here. 

Here's Rosenberg's quote

"Dr. Lawrence Rosenberg, former executive director of the Jewish General hospital and president and CEO of the Integrated Health and Social Services Network of the West-Central Montreal (CIUSSS) has just said that Covid-19 is similar to the flu virus in both danger and risk of transmission. He also mentioned that, while Covid-19 is particularly dangerous to the elderly with pre-existing conditions, the flu targets the very young as well as the very old. The Jewish General is the province's primary Covid-19 treatment center."

First off, the vast majority of deaths happened in government long-term facility homes. The sheer disaster of what happened can't be over stated. Nor do we really know if alleged Covid deaths were ever tested. Sante Publique prevented people from performing autopsies on loved ones.

It's also worth mentioning the protocol for reporting cause of death was changed by the WHO.like they did with the definition of what constitutes a pandemic in 2009.  

Officials don't speak of excess monthly deaths in Canada is no different than in past years. If they did, it would expose the lies they're peddling.

I will be looking into all deaths for 2020 to ascertain what the excess death is.

Dude made a false claim when he Covid "can leave survivors with long-term health consequences.

All viruses offer this risk. It's not a justification for the measures in place. 

Dube goes on to conflate and misrepresent Rosenberg's over all point. He wasn't saying it was symptomatically the same nor did he compare the two. All he said is they both similarly pose danger (fact) and risk of transmission (fact).

"It is clear that COVID-19 is much more severe than the seasonal flu," he said on Radio-Canada's Tout un matin Tuesday.  As time moves on, this statement looks more and more dubious. At the moment, it does pose a greater overall danger but it's also now seasonal. Dube is talking as if the virus has the same force as it had in March when we know from the deaths it isn't the case and likely in low circulation and on its way to becoming a seasonal virus not necessarily more or less dangerous as influenza.

"COVID is unquestionably much worse than a bad flu season," McGeer said, but noted Canada's influenza death rate is kept in check by vaccines. 

In 2020 it is, will it next year as we learn to cope to it and perhaps build antibodies and T-cell immunity?

As for the vaccine, that's the government playing up its fear campaign to make sure people remain afraid. But SARS Cov-2 is actually reaching flu like numbers without a vaccine.

Picture Covid as a meteor that was observed coming from space. On its descent it looks like it will crash and leave a hole in North America but instead breaks apart thanks to earth's atmospheric defense and ends up being a pebble crashing with a light thud. That's the virus. In March it came in like a meteor only to peter out. The cases are no different than cases for any other virus now. But the government weirdly continues to operate on the notion we're still in March.

This was made clear when Dube said Covid has killed 68 Quebecers per 100 000. This is true but a classic case of playing with statistics.

First, deaths by SARS Cov-2 in Canada is 23 per 100 000. It's 22 for influenza.

Second, 68 is a TRAILING figure. As in, it's already baked in. Looking at past figures don't tell us anything about the current situation. That's why it's critical to examine the numbers now and what it means moving FORWARD. If you notice, deaths have come off since June and not likely to reach those seen in the spring. That was an anomaly. 

One menacing tool of deception the government loves to use are 'projections' based on models. Because we've seen just how reliable that has been, right? Not just during the pandemic (remember when Tam said Canada could see 22 000-40 000 deaths by April? We're at 9200 in September and a vast chunk of those came in nursing homes. 

And he's flat out wrong. The data is indisputable. 

"In countries like the US, the UK, and also Sweden (without a lockdown), overall mortality since the beginning of the year is in the range of a strong influenza season; in countries like Germany, Austria and Switzerland, overall mortality is in the range of a mild influenza season."

Sweden SCHOOLED the world and laugh at Dube.

Context people. Work with me.

Legault told a reporter to stop watching CNN. Good advice.

Maybe he could do his part in stopping to spread fake news.